Comparison Guide

The 9 Best Eyelash Curlers of 2026, Tested & Ranked

We bought 9 popular eyelash curlers, from a $5 drugstore pick to $34 gold, and gave them to 25 testers for 6 weeks. Each curler was judged on ease of use, how evenly it curled, how long the curl lasted, whether it pinched, value for money, and build quality.

9Curlers Tested
6Weeks of Testing
25Testers
6Scoring Criteria
Independently Tested
We buy every product ourselves
No Sponsored Placements
Zero pay-to-play, ever
Self-Funded Reviews
No free product accepted
6-Week Minimum
6 week minimum of testing
Editorial independence: We purchased every product with our own money and don't accept sponsored placements. We may earn commissions from qualifying purchases through our links, but this never influences our rankings. Read our methodology
The Short Answer

Our Top Eyelash Curlers at a Glance

The Shiseido Eyelash Curler was our panel's best overall: light to use, with really nice curls and a spare pad, for $29. Want luxury? The Dior gave a great long-lasting curl. On a budget? The $5 e.l.f. has the same latch and pad cover as the Dior.

Our #1 Pick
★ Best Eyelash Curler Overall
Our original photos
Shiseido Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Shiseido Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Shiseido Eyelash Curler: side view
Side view

Original photos: The Lash List
Click any image to enlarge.

Shiseido Eyelash Curler

Light to use, really nice curls, and a spare pad in the box.

$29 / Spare pad: 1 included
✓ Best rated overall Spare pad included

Comes in a simple box with one spare pad. The curler feels solid, with the logo debossed into the metal, yet it is light to use, and it gave our panel really nice curls. It is not the cheapest curler here, but it was the one our panel rated best overall. The curls lasted all day even without mascara. Among our top-rated curlers, it gave better curls without pinching in testing.

Why It's Worth It

At $29 it sits towards the upper scale of the price range, but it beat the $32 Dior and $34 Hourglass on overall rating, and it includes the spare pad the Dior leaves out. Our testers felt it was worth the price in comparison to cheaper curlers or the other curlers they tested.

Also Recommended

The Luxury Pick & the $5 Budget Pick

#2 · Best Luxury Feel

Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler

The most impressive curler to hold, and our editor's favorite for feel. It gave a great long-lasting curl.

$32
#3 · Best Budget

e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler

The same safety latch and pad cover as the Dior, at about a sixth of the price.

$5
Full Rankings

All 9 Eyelash Curlers, Tested & Ranked

Each curler judged on 6 criteria, in order of importance: Ease of Use, Even Curl, Curl Hold, Pinch-Free Comfort, Value for Money, Build Quality.

Every eyelash curler bought for The Lash List test, still in retail packaging
Every curler we bought for this test

Heated lash curlers are still undergoing testing and will be updated when testing period has finished.

Best Overall

Shiseido Eyelash Curler

Shiseido
$29 · Spare pad: 1 included · Black metal, debossed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Shiseido Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Shiseido Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Shiseido Eyelash Curler: side view
Side view

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

Comes in a simple box with one spare pad. The curler feels solid, with the logo debossed into the metal, yet it is light to use, and it gave our panel really nice curls. It is not the cheapest curler here, but it was the one our panel rated best overall. The curls lasted all day even without mascara. Among our top-rated curlers, it gave better curls without pinching in testing.

  • Rated best overall by our panel
  • Really nice curls
  • Light to use
  • Spare pad included
  • Simple, no-frills box
  • Costs about six times the e.l.f. curler
Best Luxury Feel

Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler

Dior
$32 · Spare pad: None · Black soft-touch, printed DIOR logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler: side view
Side view

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

Smooth, waxy, soft-touch material that feels genuinely high-end. A plastic clasp keeps it closed in a makeup bag. It gave a great long-lasting curl. The catch is value: there is no spare pad in the box, which matters at $32. Among our top-rated curlers, it gave better curls without pinching in testing.

  • Best feel of any curler tested
  • Great long-lasting curl
  • Safety clasp for travel
  • No spare pad
  • One of the most expensive options tested
Best Budget

e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler

e.l.f. Cosmetics
$5 · Spare pad: None · Black, debossed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler: side-by-side comparison with dior curler
Side-by-side comparison with Dior curler

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

Debossed logo and the same safety latch and pad cover as the Dior. There is no spare pad, but at $5 you could buy a second curler for less than most premium curlers cost. Among our top-rated curlers, it gave better curls without pinching in testing.

  • $5
  • Same latch and pad cover as the Dior
  • Debossed logo
  • No spare pad
Best for Beginners

Hourglass Lash Curler

Hourglass
$34 · Spare pad: 1 included · Gold metal
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Hourglass Lash Curler: curler
Curler
Hourglass Lash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Hourglass Lash Curler: directions
Directions

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

The only gold curler, and it feels premium. It is heavy in the hand. One spare pad is included, and it was the only curler in our test that came with a directions-for-use leaflet, which we found helpful. Testers loved the dramatic curl and noted no pinching.

  • Only curler with printed directions
  • Spare pad included
  • Premium gold finish
  • Highest price tested
  • Heavier than all other curlers and so clunkier to use
Most Distinctive Design

Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler

Kevyn Aucoin
$26 · Spare pad: 1 included · Metal, red pads, debossed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler: spare pad
Spare pad

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

An unusual, cute design with a debossed logo and one spare pad. Similar to Shiseido design. When we checked prices, Kevyn Aucoin's own store showed it out of stock, while Bluemercury listed it at $26. Testers loved the curl but stated it only lasted a few hours. No one said it pinched the skin or lash line.

  • Unusual, cute design
  • Spare pad included
  • Similar to Shiseido design
  • Out of stock at the brand store when we checked
Best Premium Feel Under $20

Live Tinted Legacy Eyelash Curler

Live Tinted
$18 · Spare pad: 1 included · Rose gold, orange pads, debossed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Live Tinted Legacy Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Live Tinted Legacy Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Live Tinted Legacy Eyelash Curler: spare pad
Spare pad

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

The only rose gold design, with orange pads and one spare. It feels quite heavy and premium compared with others at this price, and the logo is debossed. All testers reported a nice curl which lasted all day, but all duly noted a slight pinching.

  • Heavy, premium feel for $18
  • Spare pad included
  • Only rose gold design we tested
  • Heavy in the hand
Famous, but Overpriced

Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler

Shu Uemura
$28 list · Spare pad: 1 included · Metal, debossed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler: side view
Side view

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

It feels very light, dare we say cheap, with a lot of plastic packaging. It comes in a simple box with one spare pad and a debossed logo. For a curler with this reputation, it felt a bit like a rip-off at full price. If you find it on sale, the value case improves. Testers were expecting a perfect long-lasting curl at this price point, and whilst it was a nice curl, users stated it didn’t last all day. Minimal pinching though.

  • Spare pad included
  • Debossed logo
  • Feels light and cheap for the price
  • Lots of plastic packaging
  • Felt a bit like a rip-off at full price
Thickest Pads

Revlon Triple-Step Eyelash Curler

Revlon
$12.99 · Spare pad: None · Matte silver, red pads, printed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Revlon Triple-Step Eyelash Curler: curler
Curler
Revlon Triple-Step Eyelash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Revlon Triple-Step Eyelash Curler: side view
Side view

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

Matte silver with a thick red pad on the top and bottom, the thickest we tested. The logo is printed rather than debossed, it felt stiff to close, and there is no spare pad, which is what we expected at this price. Testers said the curl was a bit too dramatic (with a harsh crease line rather than a soft curl). It also pinched a bit on the skin.

  • Thickest pads we tested, top and bottom
  • Drugstore price
  • Stiff to close
  • No spare pad
Largest Curler

Velour Too Extra Lash Curler

Velour
$15 · Spare pad: 1 included · Antique brass, white pad, printed logo
Panel scores being finalized
Our original photos3 photos · Click to enlarge
Velour Too Extra Lash Curler: curler
Curler
Velour Too Extra Lash Curler: packaging
Packaging
Velour Too Extra Lash Curler: detail
Detail

Photography: The Lash List · Curlers bought for this test

Antique brass and much larger than the other curlers. It comes with one spare pad, but the pad is white and will show dirt quickly. It feels chunky and a bit clunky, and the logo is printed rather than debossed. For those who tested Velour, users say, the curler pinched the skin quite a bit and the curl did not last as long as with our top picks.

  • Largest curler we tested
  • Spare pad included
  • Chunky and clunky
  • White pad will show eye and general make up or even dirt very clearly which is quite offputting!
Quick Reference

Eyelash Curler Comparison Chart

#CurlerPriceSpare padFinishOur verdict
1Shiseido Eyelash Curler$291 includedBlack metal, debossed logoBest Overall
2Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler$32NoneBlack soft-touch, printed DIOR logoBest Luxury Feel
3e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler$5NoneBlack, debossed logoBest Budget
4Hourglass Lash Curler$341 includedGold metalBest for Beginners
5Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler$261 includedMetal, red pads, debossed logoMost Distinctive Design
6Live Tinted Legacy Eyelash Curler$181 includedRose gold, orange pads, debossed logoBest Premium Feel Under $20
7Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler$28 list1 includedMetal, debossed logoFamous, but Overpriced
8Revlon Triple-Step Eyelash Curler$12.99NoneMatte silver, red pads, printed logoThickest Pads
9Velour Too Extra Lash Curler$151 includedAntique brass, white pad, printed logoLargest Curler

Panel scores will be added when the tally is published.

Prices are each brand's or retailer's listed US price, checked October 9, 2026. Sale prices change often.

Value for Money

Do Expensive Eyelash Curlers Work Better?

Not reliably. The curlers we tested range from $5 to $34, a nearly sevenfold spread, and price did not decide the ranking. The $29 Shiseido beat two pricier curlers. The $5 e.l.f. shares the Dior's latch and pad cover. And the $28 Shu Uemura, one of the most famous curlers in beauty, felt light and cheap for the money. Two things are worth paying for: a curve that fits your eye and a spare pad, because the pad wears out long before the metal does.

Luxury eyelash curlers tested by The Lash List
The luxury curlers we tested.
Curler (cheapest first)PriceSpare pad in the box
e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler$5None
Revlon Triple-Step Eyelash Curler$12.99None
Velour Too Extra Lash Curler$151 included
Live Tinted Legacy Eyelash Curler$181 included
Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler$261 included
Shu Uemura Eyelash Curler$28 list1 included
Shiseido Eyelash Curler$291 included
Dior Backstage Eyelash Curler$32None
Hourglass Lash Curler$341 included
Drugstore and under-$20 eyelash curlers tested by The Lash List
The drugstore and under-$20 curlers we tested.
Fit

How to Choose an Eyelash Curler for Your Eye Shape

A curler should reach nearly all your lashes without catching eyelid skin. If it curls only the middle, or pinches at the corners, the curve is wrong for your eye, not your technique.

Eye or lash typeLook forWhy
Hooded or deep-set eyesFlatter curve, slim top barGets close to the lash line without pressing on the lid.
Almond or monolid eyesWide, shallow curveCatches the outer corners as well as the center.
Round eyesMore pronounced curveFollows the eye so the corners are not missed.
Straight or stubborn lashesThick, cushioned padLets you build curl in gentle presses instead of one hard crimp.
False or strip lashesExtra-wide openingClamps natural and false lashes together.
Methodology

How We Tested and Scored Every Curler

25 testers, 6 weeks, the same six criteria for every curler, listed below in order of importance. We chose the criteria from the complaints shoppers raise most often in reviews and forums: curls that drop, pinched lids, and curlers that cost more than they deliver.

Ease of Use

How easy it is to position, squeeze, and release, especially for first-time users.

#1

Even Curl

Whether inner, center, and outer lashes lift together, or the curl stops at the middle.

#2

Curl Hold

How long the curl holds through the day.

#3

Pinch-Free Comfort

Whether it catches eyelid skin at the corners or tugs lashes on release.

#4

Value for Money

Price against performance, plus whether a spare pad came in the box.

#5

Build Quality

Weight, hinge feel, finish, pad thickness, and how well it should last.

#6

Read Our Full Methodology →

Common Questions

Eyelash Curler FAQ

Shiseido was the better buy in our test: our top pick gave better curls without pinching, and its curls lasted all day even without mascara. Shu Uemura testers expected a perfect long-lasting curl at this price point. They reported a nice curl, but said it did not last all day, with minimal pinching. At the listed prices checked October 9, 2026 ($29 for Shiseido and $28 for Shu Uemura), we would choose Shiseido. Fit still depends on your eye shape.
A higher price does not guarantee a better curl. The $5 e.l.f. Pro was our budget pick and the $32 Dior Backstage was our luxury-feel pick, using the listed prices checked October 9, 2026. Both were among our top-rated curlers, which gave better curls without pinching in testing. The e.l.f. shares the Dior's safety latch and pad cover; Dior stood out for its soft-touch feel and great long-lasting curl. Neither includes a spare pad. They are not identical in every respect, but e.l.f. offers strong value.
Our panel rated the Shiseido Eyelash Curler ($29) best overall: light to use, and it gave really nice curls. If you want something that feels more luxurious, the Dior Backstage gave a great long-lasting curl but has no spare pad. On a budget, the $5 e.l.f. Pro has the same safety latch and pad cover as the Dior.
Sometimes. Price did not line up neatly with performance in our test. The $29 Shiseido beat curlers costing more, the $5 e.l.f. shares the Dior's latch and pad cover, and the $28 Shu Uemura felt light and cheap for its price. Pay for fit, pad quality, and a spare pad, not the logo.
It is light to use, it gave our panel really nice curls, and it costs less than most premium curlers while still including a spare pad. It was the best-rated curler overall with our 25 testers.
Before. Curl clean, dry lashes, then apply mascara. Clamping lashes coated in dried mascara makes them stick to the pad and can bend or break them.
Usually the curve does not match your eye shape, or the curler is placed too close to the lid. Look down into a mirror, set the curler just in front of the lash line, and squeeze gently. If it still catches the corners, try a flatter or wider curler.
Replace the pad when it cracks, flattens, gets sticky, or leaves a crease instead of a curve. For daily users that is often every few months. A spare pad in the box adds real value, which is why we list it for every curler.
It can if you clamp too hard, curl after mascara, use a cracked pad, or pull the curler away before opening it fully. Used gently on clean lashes with a soft pad, a curler bends lashes temporarily rather than damaging them.
They work differently: heat sets the curl in place, which some people find holds longer. Our heated-curler results are still being compiled, so this ranking covers classic clamp curlers only.
Keep Reading

Related Lash List Guides

Independently Tested No Sponsorships Self-Funded 25+ Testers 6-Week Testing